When jesus abandoned america, or why tptb prefer pagan gods. Alternate timelines if this is your first visit, be sure to check out the faq by clicking the link above. A world without islam christian books, bibles, gifts. Fuller guides us along an illuminating journey through history, geopolitics, and religion to investigate. Timelines is an outstanding alternate history, and has a gold ranking, which means it has been identified as a very good timeline in the alternate history community. Sep 18, 2010 also, not being muslim, i think islam s creation was partly stimulated by arab contact with christians, so you probably would not have had islam either. Through darkest europe is an alternate history novel by harry turtledove. A world without islam presents an inflammatory title, and i truly wish that the editor would have reconsidered the title before publishing. Enter your mobile number or email address below and well send you a link to download the free kindle app. May 17, 2012 early on, the mirage reminded me of graham fullers a world without islam. In his book, fuller says, i try to run through a whole lot of events and take.
An alternate history of the american civil war, by jeffrey evans brooks, a single telegram changes the course of the civil war. Alternative history, english sf, islam in sf literature with. Canada night of the living alternate history map game. Categories some scholars classify religions as either universal religions that seek worldwide acceptance and actively look for new converts, or ethnic religions that are identified with a. Menu futurists short alternate history questions thread. Alternate timelines armchair general and historynet. This is a list of alternate history fiction, sorted by type.
And we wouldnt be talking about algebra and algorithms, unless somehow arabs become an important player on the world stage without islam to unify them. The best alternate history stories of the 20th century explore fascinating, often chilling what if accounts of the world that could have existedand still might yet. Dig out islam, fuller seems to say, and nothing really changes. Conscience and history in a world civilization 3 volumes by marshal gs hodgson.
We live today in an alternate history world as created by the likes of that commie twat jane fonda, wherein vietnam. This is an open timeline, you can edit this if you like. This europe, though, is a culturally stunted backwater that is home to the aquinists, a radical christian offshoot that rejects the modern world in favor. Futurists short alternate history questions thread history. Categories some scholars classify religions as either universal religions that seek worldwide acceptance and actively look for new converts, or ethnic religions that are identified with a particular ethnic group and do not seek converts. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer no kindle device required. How different would the world be without wwi nor wwii closed ask question asked 4 years. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Walter scheidel, who teaches classics at stanford university, aims to answer the question of why western civilization bounded past the rest of the world economically in the 18th century a phenomenon that historians generally call the great divergence.
In a world without islam, he explains that even if the religion never existed. At the hard end of plausibility are wellresearched pieces that take into account historical sources and trends, logical changes due to the butterfly effect, and try to produce. Alternate history exercise middle east without islam. Sovereign states without islam alternative history.
Articles related to canada and alternate canadas fandom. Fuller takes us from the birth of islam to the fall of rome to the rise and collapse of the. Islam main article islam etymology and meaning slm articles of faith islamic theology iman god in islam tawhid, oneness of god allah shirk, partnership and idolatory repentance in islam islamic views on sin haram kufr bidah holiest sites in islam holiest sites in sunni islam islamic holy books quran history of the quran list of surahs in. A world without islam and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. This has conditioned the dispersion, evolution and development of the religions and their cultural heritage. In a world without islam, not much would change former cia official and historian graham fuller argues that the wests fraught relationship. This timeline will show what the world will be like without islam. Luckily for you, there are a ton of allohistories that pick more obscure and interesting points of.
Refreshingly, benslama writes without ideological bias and undoes the simplistic, western view of islam while refusing to romanticize terrorism or muslim extremism. This, in effect, becomes a book about the history of the world that has nothing to do with islam. The author uses the common belief that stalin had always planned to betray hitler, but that hitler simply beat him to the punch. While the teacher in me appreciated the point of his exercise, the academic in me fretted over the perfect similarities between a world with islamour worldand fullers hypothetical world without it. Books robert irwins top 10 books on islam and islamic culture. And last but not least as the idea of parallel universes. How different it would have been, how the butterfly effects that never happened would turned out to be, and its very sobering. For an alternate world scifi novel, im trying to figure out which technologies they have. Please let us know what you think about this series so that we. Every other wednesday we will be posting an alternate history scenario, piece of art, story etc. This is a penetrating work that reveals an alternate history of the islamic religion and opens new possibilities for its future development. In his world, the medieval plagues wiped out almost the entire european population, allowing muslim kingdoms to colonize europe, and installing islam as the dominant culture of the west. A world without islam graham e fuller foreign policy.
And since we often like to be surprised, alternate histories are. Would the middle east be a peaceful beacon of democracy. So i went to and checked the divergence chronology page. The duel was nonlethal, of course, simply a tradition from older times, without the savageness. Robert irwins top 10 books on islam and islamic culture. Over the last 1400 years, from origins in arabia, a succession of muslim polities and later empires expanded to control territories and peoples that ultimately stretched from southern france, to east africa to south east asia. Futurists short alternate history questions thread. In this timeline, the prophet muhammad died as a young boy in 580 ad and did not spread the doctrine of islam. Operation downfall has also served an important political function, justifying the atomic bombings of hiroshima and nagasaki by contrasting the reallife casualties with the projected loss of life in an invasion of the japanese home islands. Sliding scale of alternate history plausibility tv tropes. Psychoanalysis and the challenge of islam university of.
He is an adjunct professor of history at simon fraser university and the author of numerous books about the middle east. In the presence of mine enemies 2003 alternate history. You cant discuss alternate history without bringing up the man in the high castle. No islam alternative history fandom alternate history wiki. But just because there are so many alternate histories being written new ones seem to come out weekly does not mean that they are all of equal quality, or equally plausible. As he was the third child, he dueled his two brothers for the right to rule. We are starting a new regular feature on islam and scifi. Fuller guides us along an illuminating journey through history, geopolitics, and religion to investigate whether or not islam is indeed the cause of some of todays most emotional and important international crises. In destiny disrupted, tamim ansary tells the rich story of world history as the islamic world saw it, from the time of prophet mohammed sallalahu alaihe wassalam to the fall of the ottoman empire and beyond. Without the german submarines attacking american ships, its unlikely that congress would have authorized war against the central powers. If we choose to see history beginning at 911 whereby we suddenly. Early on, the mirage reminded me of graham fullers a world without islam. In the alternate history of blonde roots, africans.
Thank you for raising this interesting alternate i couldnt think of anything that fit except one of poul andersons time patrol stories. Even without islam, other notion, such as nationalism, can be the vehicle for the conflict to continue on. I checked abebooks and copies still seem to be around. Napoleon and the conquest of the world by louis geoffroy, napoleon s first french empire emerging. If you see a way this alternate history can be updated or improved without compromising previous work, please say so on this pages talkpage or come on chat. It has been warped over vast periods of time to fit with each generations idea of what is fact and what is truth. I read accounts of the warinprogress, like thomas e. Islam has been one of the most powerful religious, social, and political forces in history. If you want to know what the world of 2016 would be like without the assassination of ferdinand in 1914, you need to figure out what the world would be like in 1919 end of war in our world, 1929 start of the great depression, 1939 start of world war ii, 1952 eisenhower elected, 1959 cuban revolution, 1991 dissolution of the soviet. Browse other questions tagged alternatehistory history or ask your own question. Canada without islam canada world of the rising sun canada yellowstone. History is, as justice holmes said, what the people who won say it is. When jesus abandoned america, or why tptb prefer pagan. Millions of people were killed in this tragic point in history.
Through darkest europe is harry turtledoves latest alternatehistory novel, envisioning a world where islam is the predominant religion and christianity is pretty much confined to europe. Even if the arabs unite probably much later without islam the unifying element for the other cultures disappears. A world without islam is a needed corrective, a sober call not to settle for historical pabulum and instead recall a past and recognize a present that is far more complicated and layered than any polemic would have us believe. The most unusual alternate history novels ever published. It is not defined by what any muslim wants it to be, but by what it is. May 10, 2018 without islam, empires would still rise and fall, dynasties woukd clash and religions would battle for supremacy. One of the main argument of the book is that islam is only a vehicle for the conflict to ride on, not really the actual cause.
Without islam there might have been another culture that would have done the same thing but what makes the islamic golden age so great was the fact that their empire was so huge and thus they could gather together such a massive portion of the most developed societies in the world. The future of terrorism isis, alqaeda, and the altright. Abkhazia abyssinia afghanistan africa albania angola arabia argentina armenia australia austria azerbaijan bahrain balochistan belgium benin bessarabia bosnia bulgaria burkina faso burma cambodia cameroon canada catalonia caucasia ceylon chad china colombia comoros croatia darfur denmark djibouti egypt emirates equatoria eritrea. In the alternate history of blonde roots, africans enslave. The genre has a variety of names, but it is best known as alternate history. Aug 11, 2010 in a world without islam, not much would change former cia official and historian graham fuller argues that the wests fraught relationship with the middle east is not about religion at all, but.
Johnston with john bell hood as commander of the army of tennessee in the battle of atlanta. Science fictions most illustrious and visionary authors hold forth the ul. The years of rice and salt is an alternate history novel by american science fiction author kim. Islams place would probably be taken by one or more of the monophysits versions of christianity that were losing out to catholics in. Without islam, empires would still rise and fall, dynasties woukd clash and religions would battle for supremacy. The premise of this book is to picture a world without islam. The dominant forms would probably be catholicism in north africa, copt in egypt, and syrian or armenian further east. Through darkest europe is harry turtledoves latest alternate history novel, envisioning a world where islam is the predominant religion and christianity is pretty much confined to europe. Millions of people were killed in this tragic point in. Tired of alternate history books where the axis won world war ii, or the south won the civil war. Dicks brainwarping story is set in a world where the axis powers won world war ii, and america has been divided between japan and nazi germany the brain twisting bit. His depicted world where the black death wipes out 90 per cent of europe instead of the 30% it did in our world, allowing islam and hinduism to be the dominant world religions and implacable enemies prompted harry turtledove, whose oeuvre is mostly made up of alternate history his latest series, the sixbook the war that came early 2009. While fyodor berezins red stars duology involves travel between parallel worlds, a huge part of it is devoted to the divergence of the other world from ours, so those sections can rightly be called alternate history. Codenamed operation downfall, the planned invasion of japan is a popular source of inspiration for alternate history books, comics, and even board games.
General history european history north american history south american history asian history middle eastern history african history history periods history. Alternate history a world without christianity science. Harry turtledove created a world where islam never appeared, but unfortunately for you, not necessarily for its inhabitants christianity was, if anything, even more powerful than in our time line. I could write a volume of books on just the technological implications, and additional volumes on society, culture, trade, etc etc etc. In an alternate history, one or more past events are changed and the subsequent effects on history somehow described. In fact, remove islam from the path of history, and the. Jun 11, 2009 and, given the steppe and barbarian tribes rather ready acceptance of islam in real history, perhaps we can assume a similar acceptance of christianity. Jun 21, 2014 a world without world war one offers up speculations on a history without both world wars had the archduke not been assassinated one hundred years ago this week. The title refers to a hypothetical question of what would the relationship between the west and the middle east be like had islam not come into existence. Newest alternatehistory questions worldbuilding stack. Im not used to reading nonfiction, soi found the early parts a bit dry. What would the world be like if muhammad never existed. Canada night of the living alternate history map game canada no american revolution canada no canadian confederation.
General history european history north american history south american history asian history middle eastern. List of sovereign countries in the without islam timeline. The events in the story follow a common theme of turtledoves work, transplanting one set of historical events into another setting the most prominent example being southern. The novel explores themes of history, religion, and social movements. In the world without islam i just cannot imagine the circumstances under which the byzantines would lose egypt. World unknown by john clagett 1975 seems to be the best fit. In this alternate world, the dominating muslim cultures of north africa and the middle east are. Jun 09, 2019 what if sir oswald mosley came to power in britain, ensuring edward viii never abdicates and keep the uk out of wwii. That leaves the persians intact in the middle east, although presumably that empire wouldnt last forever either.
Mar 27, 2018 battle of ain jalut, 1260 the battle that saved islam and stopped the mongols duration. Its not impossible, but it seems unlikely to happen in time for this particular institution to benefit. We passionately believe that no muslim should be harmed, harassed, stereotyped or treated any differently anywhere in the world solely on account of their status as a muslim. He clarifies why our civilizations grew up oblivious to each other, what happened when they intersected, and how the islamic world was affected by its slow recognition that. And, given the steppe and barbarian tribes rather ready acceptance of islam in real history, perhaps we can assume a similar acceptance of christianity. There might be some periods when egypt would break away from constantinople, some civil wars, pretenders for the imperial throne, riots and the like. After he won, he immediately set up a road system to be the envy of the world, on top of buying shares in one of the worlds most successful car companies, maaruti automotive. Two other early alternate history novels by turtledove are a world of difference, in which mars called minerva in the book is a habitable and. Follows the struggles of a family of secret jews in berlin, nearly 70 years after a nazi victory in world war ii. What if sir oswald mosley came to power in britain, ensuring edward viii never abdicates and keep the uk out of wwii. Going back to the idea that spacetime is flat, the number of possible particle configurations in multiple. Feb 17, 2004 books robert irwins top 10 books on islam and islamic culture. Without the existence of the secret societies, our history would have been totally different.
Alternate histories hypothetical historical scenarios. The alternate history list is a bibliography of over 3400 novels, stories, essays, collections, and other printed material involving the what ifs of history. The book is set in an alternate present in which islamic countries form a. Also, not being muslim, i think islams creation was partly stimulated by arab contact with christians, so you probably would not have had islam either. According to our history books, there was a massive earthquake in the ancient world which left effects on a global scale. Critics found the book to be rich in detail, realistic, and thoughtful. Battle of ain jalut, 1260 the battle that saved islam and stopped the mongols duration. Turtledoves first major forays into scifi and alternate history involved a byzantine imperial agent in the 0s, in a world where muhammad converted to christianity instead of founding islam. This novel imagines centuries of history in a world where 99 percent of europeans died, leaving muslim and chinese cultures in control of the. I doubt that the arabs will be as sucessful without islam islam is an unifiing concept, without each city tribe has its own though related faith and philosophy. Like other forms of speculative fiction, alternate history varies in its inherent hardness with ah fandom generally grading it by how plausible the ah is based on historical realism and verisimilitude.
546 866 642 1004 15 695 1559 831 298 581 1121 239 445 119 432 12 779 56 1445 1064 970 1529 628 1006 143 809 26 374 1118 1474 1323 1320 648 872 1080